Tags
beauty and brutality, death, Deer, deer scream, memoir, Nature, Vietnam, wildlife
The most horrifying sound I’ve ever heard came one night soon after we moved here. A scream of pure terror that seemed to last forever.
It was too dark to see. All we could hear was the sound of thundering hooves and a long endless scream passing from one end of the meadow behind our home to the other, then crashing down a ravine. There the sound suddenly stopped, as if a knife had sliced its throat.
Something running for its life had ended abruptly.
We had never heard of a deer screaming, but could not imagine what else it could have been to run so fast and so loud, so I searched online.
There various hunters confirmed that deer do indeed scream—not always, not often, but when they do, the sound is so terrifyingly awful it has haunted them ever since. One property owner who had always welcomed hunters would not allow them on his land after hearing that scream.
So much of what I write here is about nature’s beauty, how it inspires, uplifts, and nourishes us. But there’s another inescapable side to nature, darker and more brutal–nature “red of tooth and claw,” as Tennyson wrote.
I’ve seen that kind too in my own backyard–in the screaming deer running for its life, the mountain lion crouched in the tall grass devouring something unidentifiable, the rattlesnake that rose hissing and bared its fangs when I was weeding, the two coyotes taking turns digging at the gopher hole then swallowing it whole in two gulps.
Then there was the rattlesnake we slaughtered when it made its home in our backyard where our little dog plays. The whole thing was a bloody nightmare, my husband going after it with a long pruning spear. The snake lunging and hissing and retreating. Finally catching it up, cutting it in two, the headless body writhing, whipping its tail.
There’s also the traps we set to keep the rats out of our garage, the gophers out of our garden. We kill to preserve life–the life of our dog, our flowers, our lawn–to protect our home. I can’t ever imagine killing a deer or rabbit or quail for food. Yet our freezer is full of meat others bred and killed.
When we were sailing we joyously lived off the bounty of the sea, hunting, capturing, killing, and eating tuna and swordfish, scallops and lobsters.
How many silent screams went unheard in those halcyon days filled with great beauty and joy and thanksgiving.
As a boy my husband spent his days happily roaming through the hills of old Orcutt with his dog Scratch and his shotgun hunting rabbits and quail.
He hunted in the hills of Vietnam as a young marine too.
Never had he known such beauty as he did then tramping through those wild tropical jungles and lush valleys, he once told me.
He built shelters of sandbags high on a hill overlooking a distant valley quilted in rice paddies with the dark steep mountains laced in waterfalls rising behind them. 
He trudged through streams with his 30-lb backpack and machine gun strapped to his back, spellbound by the tropical flowers draping the banks, the brilliant birds darting overhead.
It was surreal—such beauty and brutality all rolled into one. Like the fields behind our home where beautiful creatures die every day to feed other beautiful creatures.
I don’t know why I’m writing this.
Perhaps just to bear witness to the beauty and brutality rolled into one all around us everywhere. We can’t separate it out. We have to swallow it whole. There’s no other way.
For a long time after my husband returned from Vietnam he carried in his wallet a faded photo, a heap of dead bodies. When he showed his uncle, he shied away from him, horrified that he would take and keep such a thing.
But he had to he told me. He couldn’t turn away.
He had to bear witness to the brutality of war. Taking that photo was his refusal to turn away. To swallow it whole.
[NOTE: Part Two of this post can be found here: A Deer's Scream, My Mother's Eyes, and a Ripe Strawberry.]
Beauty and brutality–I guess you sort of sum up human history there. Such a moving post.
Thank you. It’s a theme I keep going back to–so hard to reconcile.
Such truth in this. I also think there is a stark contrast between nature and all things man-made. Such as listening to the sounds of a natural stream contrasted with the sounds of cars flying by on the highway. The bit about screaming deer was both upsetting and fascinating to me. I never knew they made any sound at all. I once heard that vegetables scream…when they’re plucked from the land, or sliced up pre-salad…who knows. Fabulous post.
I’ve heard that about plants too, how they react to music, and being uprooted, and people talking to them. So much about the natural world we have yet to learn. It’s fascinating.
Brilliant post. Thanks so much for writing this… So many ignore the “silent screams” (beautifully said) that OF COURSE are just as pervasive as these creatures’ beautiful presences. And while Nature has its order, it’s imperative that we acknowledge this other side — in order to treat these fellow animals with respect and love.
If more were cognizant of these silent screams, humane changes would quickly occur in the slaughterhouses; more people would seek out humane food sources, etc. We’re all here together, and we can *all* suffer and enjoy life equally. p.s. — I’ve heard the screaming, and it’s heart-wrenching. I also had friends live near a horse slaughter plant, and heard their screams. Other animals scream as well, but at levels not heard to the human ear (rats and mice come to mind). Puts things in perspective…
Yes, I think that bearing witness, that refusal to turn away, does help us lead more compassionate lives. Thank you for adding your comment to this page.
Well written. Good job digging deep and facing the difficult things.
Thank you, glad you stopped by.
I absolutely love the way you write! And you are right – we are kindred spirits. I’m definitely looking forward to reading more when I get home. You’re very talented.
Thank you Maggie. I’m so glad I found your blog!
That was a really beautiful post… I have always tried to see the good side of everything and have shied away from the darker side, have even done my best to change it… But this post has really got me thinking now… I really love the way you weave your words…
Cheers,
Sumithra.
Thank you, Sumithra. I really appreciate your taking the time to leave this comment.
I read this again today and had to comment again. The moral struggle you identify between eating meat and yet being unable to bear the idea of killing an animal for food is something I’ve fought with my whole life. You are doing a brave thing by facing the brutality, and you do a beautiful job of balancing this internal conflict and tying it to other aspects of the nature of animals and people. I really enjoy this piece.
It’s been a dilemma for me too, something I still struggle with–thanks for writing.
Wow. Such a beautiful yet sad post. My husband and I walk past so many deer on our travels through the trails near our home. I’ve never heard them make a sound, and just the other day, I wondered aloud to my husband if they do. Now I know. And I don’t think I’ll ever be quite the same for knowing that.
Thank you. Beautifully written. Beautifully done.
I know–hearing that sound really made a profound change in my life too. Thank you so much leaving this comment.